I call retouching on dove.
I’m fascinated by the continued coverage of the most recent video in the Dove Real Beauty Campaign arsenal. Though much of the coverage has been critical, its very discussion shows how effective the campaign has been—and how ready women are for a new conversation about beauty, one that doesn’t rest on the belief that we don’t like the way we look.
I’ve heard from several readers who have pointed out that whatever quibblings I might have with the Dove campaign, the fact is that it’s better for women than traditional advertising, specifically the type that relies on sexist tropes. I agree: At the end of the day, if I had to choose between Dove’s “BFF marketing” style and the rest of ’em, I’d choose Dove. (And I’ll readily point out that the sketch artist ad “worked” on me: I totally got teary at the big reveal.) But as Cassie points out, we’re not limited to either/or options here, and as cynical as I might be about advertising, I'd feel more cynical if I just threw up my hands and said, Well, this is the best we can do, so I'll take it.
I’ve heard from several readers who have pointed out that whatever quibblings I might have with the Dove campaign, the fact is that it’s better for women than traditional advertising, specifically the type that relies on sexist tropes. I agree: At the end of the day, if I had to choose between Dove’s “BFF marketing” style and the rest of ’em, I’d choose Dove. (And I’ll readily point out that the sketch artist ad “worked” on me: I totally got teary at the big reveal.) But as Cassie points out, we’re not limited to either/or options here, and as cynical as I might be about advertising, I'd feel more cynical if I just threw up my hands and said, Well, this is the best we can do, so I'll take it.
More to the point: I’m not so sure that the roots of the Dove campaign are all that different from conventional ads, though the feeling each creates is quite different. The Dove campaign exploits women’s beauty-related self-esteem for its own purposes. In other words, it’s doing exactly the same thing as the ads that tell women they aren’t good enough as-is. The means are different, of course, but the tool of leverage—and, of course, the end goal of selling products—is the same: Without a self-esteem crisis, neither type of ad would work. It’s this bare fact—that without women disliking their looks, Dove would lose its ace in the hole—that should make us suspect of the premise. Do women feel bad about their looks? Yes! Sometimes. Sometimes.
The feminist argument against beauty advertising often hinges upon a neat equation: Companies need to make women feel bad about the way they look, so that they can then supply the fix—lipstick, hair conditioner, whatever. Contrast this with what people within the beauty industry (like the beauty editor I interviewed here) say: The beauty industry has a stake in making women feel good about themselves, by giving us tools of independent self-care and the ability to enhance our natural gifts. At first glance these two arguments seem pitted against one another, but in fact they exist in symbiosis. The beauty industry has a stake in keeping women in the space between desperate unhappiness with our looks and bulletproof self-esteem. A consumer who simultaneously believes that she is beautiful and not-beautiful makes for a better consumer. And in fact it’s simple for advertisers to leverage our chronic cognitive dissonance because that’s closer to the actual experience of beauty than some neat yes/no box. If there was no part of us that didn’t secretly believe we just might be beautiful, the Dove ad would have no effect. It’s not only the possibility but the permission of the Dove ad that makes it so powerful.
Yes, there’s an enormous problem with appearance-related self-esteem among women (and men). Yes, we need to continue to address this concern on a sociological level. Yes, it is incredibly painful for any of us in those moments of exquisitely vulnerable self-loathing. Yes to all that. And yet: Yes, most of us have looked in the mirror at some point and liked what we’ve seen. Yes, we look forward to wearing certain outfits because we know we look fantastic in them. Yes, we now snap so many self-portraits that we had to invent the word selfie to describe the phenomenon. Yes to all the natural human joy and pride and immodesty and pleasure we take in our looks. To deny that side of the beauty question is to deny our lived experience. To deny that side of the beauty question is to take shame in those moments of pride, to deny ourselves lest we be seen as thinking we’re “all that.” To deny that side of the beauty question is to publicly deny other women the same right we privately give ourselves. We don’t give ourselves that right all the time, no. But we don’t need to.
I’d be hesitant to put this thought out there, that maybe we like the way we look at the same time we don’t like the way we look—because really what I’m saying is that this is true for me, and my my, isn’t someone arrogant? But when I look at the numbers—the numbers we don’t hear about all the time in clucking tones—I see that my experience of beauty duality isn’t mine alone. Check out the numbers that writer and sociology PhD candidate Kjerstin Gruys points out: According to another study, 58% of women are satisfied with their appearance. 65% of women consider themselves “above average” in appearance. Or, hell, look at Dove’s own numbers from their 2004 research for the launch of the Real Beauty campaign: While only 4% of the Dove survey respondents copped to considering themselves “beautiful,” 55% of them were satisfied with their body shape and size. One of these numbers works in the narrative Dove is creating with the Real Beauty campaign. And one of them doesn’t.
Add to that the other structural concerns Virginia Postrel points out about the Dove video: We only see the results of seven women; 20 women participated in the initial experiment. (Did some of those women’s sketches fall out of line with the desired result?) The sketch artist—i.e. the person whose work the entire ad centers around—knew what the experiment while doing his sketches. There was no opportunity for women to correct the sketch as would happen if the goal actually were accuracy; how would someone know whether what she called her “long nose” differed wildly from the artist’s rendering of it?
And there’s that word beautiful, which, according to Dove research, only 4% of women describe themselves as being. What Dove doesn't tell you is how they came up with that number: They asked survey respondents to choose one word to describe themselves from a list of 10 words. Here’s a list of the words respondents were given to choose from (on page 10): natural, average, attractive, feminine, good-looking, cute, pretty, beautiful, sophisticated, sexy, stunning, and gorgeous. Does me choosing, say, sexy, or pretty, or natural or attractive signal a self-esteem problem? Hell, even choosing average doesn’t mean we're suffering—if you’re approaching the question from a statistical standpoint instead of an interpretive one (and some respondents undoubtedly would), by definition most of us would indeed be average. (Speaking of averages: When respondents were asked to place themselves on a “bell curve” of beauty, 13% of respondents said they thought of themselves as somewhat less or much less beautiful than other women. And 16% of respondents said they thought of themselves as somewhat more or much more beautiful than other women.)
But back to why I bothered to revisit the campaign in the first place: I think some of us have had enough. Just as Dove created the campaign in response to the fact that women had had enough of traditional advertising that asked us to feel lesser-than, it’s clear from the overwhelming response to the ad that while we’ve still had enough of that type of ad, we’re also becoming wary of the ads that use those feelings as leverage. And frankly, I’m thrilled to see such a variety of responses to the campaign. To me, it signals a desire to shed the therapeutic narrative of beauty. The question is: What narrative will we design in its place?
you are brilliant.
ReplyDeleteWow, thank you! Much appreciated.
DeleteI've been reading for a while by way of already pretty. This is just so smart and nuanced. I've come late to fashion, style and "frivolity" (42). One thing that's helped has been getting mature and less apologetic as a feminist and a human being. But for sure another thing that has helped is this and other feminist blogs. I so appreciate that you (and others) are facilitating sophisticated conversations about this shit - and doing it in a way that is humane and kind. It gives me hope for my sons and daughter. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteThis is a truly humbling comment--thank you. I'm pleased to be able to host a conversation--and thrilled that so many people want to be in on these types of conversations.
DeleteThat survey question actually makes me quite angry! (my day job as a social researcher coming through I think)
ReplyDeleteHa! I had been wondering how this would hold up critically through that lens. The study was done by good researchers (among them Nancy Etcoff, who wrote "Survival of the Prettiest") but the fact remains that it was paid for by Dove, which the study designers knew. How could there not be some implicit bias?
DeleteSo glad to see some in depth criticism of this ad. You are so right on this:
ReplyDeleteJust as Dove created the campaign in response to the fact that women had had enough of traditional advertising that asked us to feel lesser-than, it’s clear from the overwhelming response to the ad that while we’ve still had enough of that type of ad, we’re also becoming wary of the ads that use those feelings as leverage.
I think it's great that more people are becoming aware of how our feelings and emotions are leveraged when being advertised to.
Personally, when I saw the ad, I did a HUGE eye roll.
Superhero Shredding
ReplyDeleteSuperhero Shredding Review
pate crepes
ReplyDeletegaufres
madeleine
mayonnaise
cookies
couscous
brownies
pate crepes
Recette Aubergine Farcie
Recette Aubergine
Gaufres
Les meilleures recettes
Wonderful Cities
How to reduce oily skin
Best foundation for oily skin
The best make up for oily skin 2013
The best primer for oily skin
Powder Foundation for oily skin
Oily skin solution
Best-Moisturizer-For-Oily-Skin
Mineral make up for oily skin
Best-Natural-Moisturizer-Oily-Skin
prepare-oily-skin-before-makeup
Ideas for best makeup for oily skin
Get the best mekeup for oily skin
Best tips for oily skin
How to choose your make up
Natural make up solution
Wonderful Cities
مسلسل العشق الاسود - الحلقة 4 الرابعة
ReplyDeleteمسلسل العشق الاسود الحلقة 3 الثالثة
مسلسل عيون القلب الحلقة 17 السابعة عشر
No Crunch Ab Answer
ReplyDeleteNo Crunch Ab Answer Review
No Crunch Ab Answer Bonus
Wrap Him Around Your Finger
ReplyDeleteWrap Him Around Your Finger
Wrap Him Around Your Finger
zd0720san antonio spurs jerseys
ReplyDeletecowboys jerseys
pittsburgh steelers jersey
cartier watches
mont blanc outlet
rolex watches
arthur jones jersey,deonte thompson jersey,courtney upshaw jersey,timmy jernigan jersey,jeromy miles jersey,haloti ngata jersey,joe flacco jersey,steve smith sr jersey
the north face jackets
saints jerseys
the north face outlet
michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet,michael kors outlet online,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors
hermes birkin
swarovski uk
oklahoma city thunder jerseys
rolex watches uk
golden state warriors jerseys
colts jerseys
burberry outlet
ysl outlet
dwyane wade jersey
cleveland cavaliers jersey
cheap nike shoes
201592dongdong
ReplyDeletemichael kors handbags
coach factory outlet
michael kors outlet online
burberry scarf
hollister clothing
toms shoes
coach factory outlet
gucci handbags
longchamp handbags
pandora charms
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
jordan 11
coach outlet online
ray ban sunglass
coach outlet
louis vuitton
prada shoes
jrodan retro
toms outlet
ghd hair straighteners
coach factory
oakley sunglasses
uggs outlet
lebron james shoes
michael kors
ray bans
louis vuitton
ray ban outlet
coach factory outlet
nike trainers
nike outlet,nike shoes,nike store,nike air max,nike free run,air max,nike free,nike blazers
The author could present the topic in new dimensions of viewpoints. It was a great reading experience. Thanks for sharing this brilliant post!
ReplyDelete