Friday, May 9, 2014

On Ladymags and Liberty

A tale prompted by the Brooke Burmingham/Shape story, in which the magazine requested that Birmingham cover up her loose-skinned abdomen for a photo accompanying a story on her 170-pound weight loss:

Some years ago, I was freelancing at a women's magazine that did cute little "factoids" about staffers on the magazine's masthead, i.e. the "cast list" of all the editors and designers and other staff members—and, as at this magazine, freelance copy editors. That particular month, the "factoid" was to be "celebrity lookalikes," in which selected people on the masthead would share a celebrity comparison they'd heard about themselves.

I'd heard a smattering of celebrity lookalikes for myself over the years, but one immediately came to mind: Jack Palance. In college, one of my teachers said to me, apropos of nothing, "Something about you reminds me of Jack Palance"—as in then-octogenarian one-armed push-up performer Jack Palance of Shane, Halls of Montezuma, and City Slickers—which was hilarious. I submitted Jack Palance as my celebrity lookalike, partly in hopes that it would serve as an antidote to the string of other staffers who would be pointing out their resemblance to, say, Amanda Peet. (As it were, I underestimated at least one staffer, whose celebrity comparison was E.T.)

A few days later, a pert art assistant swung by my cubicle and asked if she could take a snapshot of me for the masthead. I knew that usually staffers supplied their own photos for such purposes, and asked why I needed my photo taken. She said as she took a couple of snapshots of me, "Oh, if we run it you can use whatever photo you want, but for now the editor just wants to make sure you're pretty enough that we can make a joke about you looking like Jack Palance." Cheese!

Left: Autumn Whitefield-Madrano. Right: Jack Palance.

*     *     *     *     *

My sympathies in the Birmingham/Shape bit instinctively go to Birmingham, for reasons that are too obvious to bother with here, though I will (perhaps tediously) point out the irony of a woman who is being hailed for her successful weight loss being asked to cover up one of the side effects of that very success. Seeing the loose flesh that often accompanies extreme weight loss doesn't neatly fit into the weight-loss-as-achievement narrative that magazines like Shape love to trumpet—in the photo in question, Birmingham is proudly smiling, showing that she doesn't consider her loose skin a detriment to her successful weight loss, but it does fly in the face of the idea that weight loss is some magic key to looking the way you've always dreamed.

Yet I have sympathy for the Shape editors as well. I've never worked at Shape, but I've worked at magazines like it, and while I'm hesitant to apply any one rule to any group of people, I will say that while the women's magazine industry attracts all sorts, one sort in particular they attract is someone who genuinely wants to make women's lives better. The ways different staff members might try to achieve that varies, but ladymags are pretty competitive, and most people don't just "fall into" them; they seek out these jobs, and it's often driven by a passion for women's issues, whether that be fitness or reproductive health or general health or politics or fashion or whatever.

But whatever role little-f or capital-F feminism plays in women's magazines, there's one way in which they will never be feminist, and that is their reliance on advertising. As long as a women's magazine depends upon advertising dollars to support its editorial content, it cannot be feminist. I say "women's magazine" in particular because most magazines rely upon advertising to stay afloat, but most magazines do not have to bend their editorial content in order to grease relationships with those advertisers. For the definitive breakdown of how this happens, read Gloria Steinem's brilliant "Sex, Lies, and Advertising" (PDF here), an essay about the early days of Ms. magazine and trying to get advertising dollars for it. In short: in women's magazines, there's an expectation that advertisers will get preferential treatment in editorial pages. A "beauty editor's secret find" might well be that individual's secret find; just as likely, it's an offering from a company that buys a lot of ad pages in the magazine. In the Ms. essay, Steinem lays out how these expectations were made explicit. I've never been privy to discussions at that level, so I have no idea how explicit those expectations are at ladymags today. What I do know is that most staff members understand that relationship at a level that they no longer think to question it: Of course, if company X needs a product mention on that page, we'll give it to them. Eyes might be rolled, but it stops there, because they—we—understand that that's just how it works.

So what does this have to do with Brooke Birmingham's loose flesh? Everything. If you accept the implicit (or explicit) condition that any part of your content can be dictated by advertisers, you cannot keep the reader's needs as the sole priority of your work. That's not to say that editors don't do excellent work that benefits the reader; they do, all the time. But once advertiser needs encroach upon editorial liberty, your own liberties as an editor feel encroached upon, even if they're not directly touched by advertisers. You begin to make preemptive decisions to avoid trouble, knowing that you have to choose your battles—whether to your top editor, or the editor-in-chief, or to "ad side," the team of people who essentially make sure you have a job. And sometimes those preemptive decisions might be something like looking at a photo of a woman with some not-so-conventionally-pretty fleshy folds around her waist, and quietly determining that that particular battle just isn't worth it. You tell yourself you're doing more of a service to the reader if you show a picture of the ideal—the magical weight loss that doesn't result in immovable "proof" of what you've "overcome"—so that she doesn't get discouraged from making the choices the entire editorial mission of the magazine supports. You make a note to yourself to pitch a story about how to "fix" that loose flesh, because that's what readers want, right? A fix? What you might not make note of is the fundamental connection here: "fixing" readers is what the ad dollars that pay your rent are built upon. Some of your corporate sponsors do it with tenderness (Dove, for example); some do it with savvy (M.A.C.); some might still resort to the old-fashioned don't-hate-me-because-I'm-beautiful technique. But fixing is the name of the game, and it is really, really hard to break out of that narrative as an editor who really is trying to provide a service to the reader. "Service" is framed as solving a problem. And a concrete problem—loose flesh—with a concrete fix (surgery?) is simpler and more readable than an in-depth investigation of the untold side of weight loss.

I'm not exactly defending Shape. It was a lousy, cowardly choice (and, as The Gloss points out, throwing a freelancer under the bus is a lazy way of handling things; I have little doubt that this came from the editors, not the writer), and I'm glad that Birmingham's story is coming to light, because while I'm doubtful that conventional ladymags will ever change in this way because of the framework they're built upon, it's showing that there are plenty of people who don't want a neat "fix"-type story but rather a more complicated journey of weight loss. Shape should do better, but I think I recognize where this came from, and it's not a place of spite; it's a place of status quo.

The best editors out there are able to keep their mission as an advocate for their readers as their highest priority. There are plenty of examples out there of magazines and editors that consistently try to tell a different story other than the "let's fix you" angle. But that is not the default, and within the current way that women's magazines are funded, I don't know if it ever will be.


  1. Brilliant and insightful, as always. Thank you.

  2. very good story, I admired those who could lose weight, and reduce a lot. certainly it is very difficult.

  3. Thank you for sharing information. I like it.
    Kizi 7 | Kizi 9

  4. all what you presented here and I've read that it is good for my work
    everything makes me happy,thanks.

  5. Thank you for sharing information

  6. I really appreciate this blog. Thanks for nice article.

  7. This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.
    Juegos Friv
    Yepi 4
    Yepi 1

  8. TRX Australia are nothing but pendants that you can attach to any form of jewelry you like.
    A revolutionary online retail store with a difference, yes I am talking about the trx workouts.
    Be it gifts or trx australia it provides the essence of style and quality that can't be justified by words.
    Trx Workouts offers you a wide variety of charms.
    Let's just have a look into some of the trx workouts that may interest you.
    These are only a few, there is whole host of trx Australia that are available and can easily ship them for you at very nominal rates, as per order.
    Most of the TRX workouts present here are actual collectible jewellery items.
    Possessing a TRX Australia is a matter of pride and a matter of envy for the onlookers.

  9. This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.

    WP She’s Viral Pro |
    Kizi 2015 |
    Juegos 2015

  10. Play the latest games here. Please join me in sharing. thanks my friend

  11. I would like to thank you for your nicely written post
    The place to play all games unblocked online. Here you can find every blocked games such as: unblocked games , unblocked games happy , unblocked games 77 ,

  12. have best online games from internet. our site update new games from Mad, Friv, Kizi, Yepi, Y8. Play fun games now.

  13. Amazing!I also wish him good luck to defend his gold medal. I like to share it with all my friends and hope they will also encourage him.
    Best organic seo service

  14. My partner and I stumbled over here from a different web page and thought I might check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward to going over your web page repeatedly.
    Cost effective web designing

  15. Favorite Things 2010

    Oprah Favorite Things 2010 showcased several wonderful items perfect for Christmas. Viewers at home watched as the shows audience sobbed, screamed and squealed when Oprah revealed her favorite things for 2010 since audience members received amazing gifts from Oprahs list. Winfreys favorite things through the years have always been pretty darn good. Those lucky enough to sit in the audience during this episode got to see a Nike Air Max 2010 Mens performance by the Black Eyed Peas and received gifts such as TVs and even week long Caribbean cruises.

    Oprah favorite things for 2010 included the book A Course in Weight Loss, Nike Air Max 90 Andrew Walker Hair Care Products, Bakers Edge Baking Pans, Ralph Lauren cashmere sweaters, Dream Homes designer candles, Breville nonstick panini grill, Jay Zs Decoded, 3D Bravia Sony television, Nike Nike Air Max 2014 Kids Free Run+ shoes, Kyocera ceramic knives and many, many more items! Its Nike Air Max Classic BW no wonder Oprahs audience sobbed, screamed and squealed when they received these amazing items! With Christmas around the corner, Oprah really helped them cut down on shopping! The things Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse Couple those lucky son of a guns dont want, they can wrap up and give away.

    Below are pictures of just some of Oprah favorite things for 2010. She really made sure to go out with a bang since this will be her final year on air. Each year Oprah been able to dupe her audience into thinking they were attending a show for another topic while Nike Air Max 2012 Heels Womens they were really there to get mega goodie bags containing her favorite things. This year, the fake topic was meditation! Yeah, it really seemed like some of those people needed to take a break and breath because they were so excited. Then again who wouldnt be excited if they get such awesome?

  16. Mario Games | kizi :Top free games. Please click and play all free online.

  17. This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative Information.

  18. Thanks for providing such useful information. I really appreciate your professional approach.
    West Palm Beach Orthodontist

  19. Thank you. I will be passing this along, I am very happy to get this post and comment here.sales training

  20. Good info and Thanks for this.
    google seo company

  21. This was a really outstanding post. In theory I would like to compose like this too - taking time and real effort to make solid Information.
    retail sales training

  22. The topic here i found was really effective to the topic which i was researching for a long time. Thanks
    field sales training

  23. Thanks for providing such useful information. I really appreciate your professional approach.
    royal palm beach orthodontist

  24. Congratulation for the great post. Those who come to read your Information will find lots of helpful and informative tips.
    best orthodontist in west palm beach

  25. I am glad I found this blog. Brilliant and wonderful job.
    sales coaching

  26. I was delighted to find this web site.I wanted to thank you for your time reading this wonderful! I really enjoyed every bit of it and I've marked to ensure that the blog post something new.
    sales strategy

  27. Wonderful post. I am searching awesome news and idea. What I have found from your site, it is actually highly content. You have spent long time for this post. It's a very useful and interesting site. Thanks!
    sales consultancy

  28. is directory flash games online: action games, shooting games, racing games and dress up girls games. We add new games daily for you to play for free! || ozov games

  29. Thanks for sharing what's on your heart today.

    As we discussed, you know exactly what you're doing and where you're going. There is no doubt about that, whatsoever. I enjoy your friendship immensely, and have a world of faith in you.
    jocuri kizi 3 | juegos friv 2| y4 | juegos friv 100 | Jeux de kizi 2 | action game | kizi 3

    Thank you for your friendship and the time you spent. Those moments changed my day — heck, the rest of the year and then some. I appreciate your faith and perspective.
    No, not at all, Iwinski said. "Having said that, if they were delivery on Oct 8 and they would declare it before us, then we would look, I don't know, for Nov or something. Because there are so few RPGs that it's really a very ridiculous concept to provide them simultaneously."
    yepi4 | yepi2 | kizi200 | juegos kizi 3 | kizi78 | friv200 | kizi 2 games

    Thank you, Bill. It's on days such as these that the very sweetness of friendship acts like a natural and refreshing condiment subduing the other flavors and feelings I was experiencing.
    wow your site is amazing, keep share with us. very nice interior, i love all. thanks for share :)
    yepi7 | juegos kizi 4 | jogos kizi 2 | frin2 | jogos yepi 4 | kizi100 | frip10

    wow your site is amazing, keep share with us. very nice interior, i love all. thanks for share :)
    kizi5 | friv251 | friv2015 | kizi99

  30. Do not know what to say, I liked your article and I hope you will have many entries or more.
    hulk games
    mickey mouse games
    agar io
    zombie games

  31. The share is fantastic I wish for your information to be shared very widely, and I'll share it on my blog Kizi blog. Thanks a lot.
    Kizi juegos